Soap Opera Digest 08/15/00
Did Somebody Say Macdonald?

by Adam Kelley

Springfield's Dark Prince Has Everyone Talking About The LIGHT


First came ANOTHER WORLD and a bit part as a college jock jonesing for Jenna. Then there was a stint on the now-defunct teen soap SWAN'S CROSSING, with Sarah Michelle Gellar ("She was only 14, but frighteningly professional"), 10 episodes administering last rites to a dying Ava on LOVING, and a few more prosecuting Rachel for murder on ONE LIFE TO LIVE. For David Andrew Macdonald, they were all ideal parts--a little blah, maybe, but certainly brief, which was all that mattered. "My agents and I had agreed that I wouldn't audition for any contract roles on soaps," he explains. "Nothing against them--I just wanted to do as much stage work as possible."
Then AW made him an offer he couldn't refuse. "They were like, 'We've got this crazy contract role, and we don't know of anyone who could really pull it off, except you.'" Of course, that wasn't literally true ("I don't think they could afford Robert DeNiro"), but Macdonald was still intrigued, especially when the character turned out be a disfigured 221-year-old time-traveling mad scientist. And so began the Lumina storyline--and backlash. "It was wacky, and it had its detractors," nods the actor, who did double duty as Jordan Stark (wearing an adhesive mask that ripped his skin "down to the muscle tissue") and his modern-day alter ego, David Halliday. "Some people worried that it was untraditional--too sci-fi, too DAYS OF OUR LIVES."

For his part, the actor thinks Lumina was an interesting riff on Gothic romance, but that backstage politics and power struggles smothered much of its potential. "It wasn't spun as well as it could have been," he sighs. In his view, that may have been because too many parties--the producers, the writers, NBC and Procter & Gamble--were vying for alpha male status.




Just The Facts
Born On: June 1
Hails From: Washington, D.C.
Cocktail Cravings: Manhattans & Rob Roys
Must-See TV: The Discovery Channel.
"To me, the mating habits of the dung beetle
are more interesting than FRIENDS."
He Drives: A Subaru Outback
Alma Maters: Colorado College & Juilliard
What He Gets at McDonald's: "Heartburn."

"When you throw that many people into the mix, and everybody (wants the final say), sometimes the story falls short. At one point, the network wanted to have Taylor Stanley's character, Remy, turn out to be alien. The writers just had to put their foot down that time. They were like, 'We will not do that.'"

Today, a year after AW's cancellation, Macdonald is confident that his storyline, however popular or unpopular it may have been, did not hasten the show's demise. "It would be unbelievably arrogant for me to say that. I've jokingly said it a few times--'Hi, I'm David Macdonald, the man who killed ANOTHER WORLD'--but it's ridiculous. You can't make seven months of story (the scapegoat) for a show that's been around for 35 years. There are plenty of other shows that have absurd storylines, if that's all we can say the Lumina story was.

But storylines are small, compared to the things that happen at the corporate level," he continues. The real problem, he says, was that AW spent its final years "dealing with a relatively hostile network. I think if different people had owned us or held investments in us, the show could have survived. But as it was, I think that even if we had had the (high) ratings of DAYS OF OUR LIVES, someone might still have been trying to get us off the air. It just wouldn't have been as easy."

Like many of his former co-stars, Macdonald found another chair on daytime when the music stopped. "Of course, I wish (AW) could have continued," he sighs, "But I love GUIDING LIGHT now. God, I'm a prince on an island that's higher than it is wide." Moreover, the dastardly Edmund performs an important public service. "I know what he does to Richard and Cassie is awful, but people write to me and say, 'Thank you so much for giving that self-righteous bitch her comeuppance," he laughs. "And it's true! It's like, 'Well, excuse me, Miss Perfect.' Same goes for my brother."

Never having met an actual prince ("As a good ol' Irish-Scottish revolutionary, I don't really go for the royals"), Macdonald doesn't have anything concrete on which to base Edmund. Luckily, the character's not that much of a stretch. "I come from a fairly well-off, white-collared background, so I think my personal experiences are probably much closer to Prince Edmund than to a construction worker. I would have to do a lot more research to play the construction worker."


Not that he couldn't play blue collar just as well as blue blood. "I hope I could, at least, because that's what I'm trained to do as an actor," he notes. So is there anyone he absolutely would not be able to play? "You mean, like an illiterate black man living in Mississippi in 1920? That would be a stretch," he muses. "Obviously, I'm not black, but I am a man. And even that...does that mean I should never play Lady Bracknell in The Importance of Being Earnest? She's a great character. With enough research, I should be able to play her, if you're thinking theoretically. I'd be a 6-foot-3, 220-pound gigantic Lady Bracknell, coming in like a frigate in the harbor. It would be a blast. But at some point I might say, 'You know, there are plenty of women who could do a better job at this more quickly than I could.'"

Of course, there may come a day when he has all the time he needs to practice. With a new head writer (Claire Labine) now settling in at GL, conventional wisdom says some characters will be axed to make room for new ones--and unattached meanies like Edmund often go first. "It's definitely something I've thought about," admits Macdonald, who has more than two years left on his contract. "But I feel fairly secure. I'm sure many people out there can't stand me, but I think I've garnered just a modicum of popularity, and Edmund is involved with a lot of other really popular people. And I think I've done a pretty good job with what they've given me. If I thought I had screwed up, I would admit it."

All that being the case, he's prepared for anything. "If they came up to me and said, 'We can't use you anymore, it's an artistic and business decision,' I wouldn't take it personally. I'd just say good-bye to everyone, go have a drink, regret the fact that I just purchased a house--maybe from the top of the Brooklyn Bridge--and then I'd do what all actors do, which is go out and look for more work."

The Royal Family
After six years of marriage, David Macdonald and his wife, Nicolette, have all the trappings of domesticity: a new house in the New Jersey suburbs, a subscription to Consumer Reports and two ticking biological clocks. "But I just turned 39 and she's only 30, so mine is racing at a different speed than hers," he laughs. "If children went on sale half-price at Crate & Barrel, she'd be there in a heartbeat, but I think the idea of childbirth is a little daunting to her. And I haven't put a lot of pressure on her by any means, which perhaps indicates that I'm not ready, either. But, hopefully, in a couple of years, after we've set up the house, we'll have a nice Catholic brood of 10."